Let Teachers Find their Ways that Work
I wrote the comments below after reading the post reached via the link:
Whatever successes I was able to glean for myself and my students did not come easily, except under the best of circumstances, which were short-lived for me and may elude most teachers. But what I did learn, and rather quickly, is that what worked for me might not necessarily work for other teachers -- and vice versa. And what worked with a particular subject, grade level and student group might not work with one that was different in one or more ways. Indeed, as teachers have repeatedly found, what worked in period 2 might not work in period 3, even though the factors mentioned above appeared to be basically the same.
As a high school teacher teacher, I have taught, usually, close to one hundred and fifty or more students (mostly regular-ed) each day, usually in at least two subjects. Too often, I have had curricula to teach that were far too broad, given the time available and the multiple and varied educational deficits the students generally have.
These deficits become clear if one cares to collect and carefully check homework, ask and encourage questions to and from all students and get other kinds of feedback. But, as sincere teachers know, all of that takes a great deal of time and effort. Most of the advocated shortcuts give a very superficial picture, at best.
Given all of this, I rarely found time to interact, closely, one-on-one, with any one student, during my class-periods, for more than a minute or two a day. This was because other students -- and the much maligned task of traditional "teaching" itself, also needed attention.
The main exceptions to this were:
a) during small -group or individual tutoring, usually before or after school hours, with or without pay;
b) during silent reading and writing assignments, provided the more restive students in the class allowed the relative quiet needed for this, permitting me to circulate and quietly be of some help to individual students or to pairs.
When I was "subbing" frequently in schools where teachers were kind enough to leave such assignments, I got to know some students rather well. I learned much about them that was surprising, sobering and intriguing.
But if I were truly able to focus more on this individual interaction, I think I would have found yet more that would surprise me -- of individual strengths, weaknesses and varied human circumstances.
I have given this particular, individual history because it is all I truly have on which to base my understanding in these matters of formal teaching and learning in the schools. I am sure that the experiences of others will have been different.
Nevertheless, I will now dare to use my own personal experience as the background for, or springboard to, a rather sweeping general statement, with which I think most teachers with some experience will agree:
Teaching and learning are difficult enough, again except in the best of circumstances. So it is best to let teachers and students find their particular ways.
There is no harm in exposing them to ways that are different from the ones they use -- but one should exercise forbearance in this. Impositions do far more harm than good.
Again, what I say is based mostly on my particular personal experience teaching (mainly) the sciences in the New York City High Schools for the past 27 years. Others may or may not agree with the generalization I made above. That is all for the good. I would like to hear from them.
Teaching and learning, formal and informal, constitute the active, participatory transmission and development of human culture. This includes outlooks, values, languages formal and informal, skills of diverse kinds, disciplines and their organized knowledge, the wonder of exploration and questioning and the sincere and difficult search for non-trivial answers...
As such, teaching and learning are far too vital, for our collective and individual survival, to be left to the mercies of fads, dogmas, zealots, careerists and yes-persons.
There are no substitutes for the traditional virtues long recognized as needed to be students and teachers who are truly sincere and successful (in the humblest sense of that last word). These include, of course, sincerity, respect, attention and diligence on the part of both teacher and student. The teacher, even more than the student, needs to have an open mind and an open heart.
This may sound utopian. But without these things, or at least without these things as guideposts, we lose our way and wander into the deserts of cynicism and cruelty.
But neither teachers nor students can succeed for long if the structures and resources needed for formal education are lacking or counterproductive -- or if the social fabric is torn beyond repair.
I have touched on these things earlier, for instance in the post:
On Social and Educational Pathologies
I should remark here that formal education, with all its strengths, is no substitute for the informal education that was traditionally obtained from the home and the community.